IQGeo blog

Navigating underground utility constraints for district energy projects

Written by Kurt Marlein, Product Manager at IQGeo | 05 July 2024

When planning and designing a district heating network, it is crucial to consider the existing utilities in the underground infrastructure. This consideration is not just a matter of convenience but a significant factor in controlling the overall costs of the project, minimizing disruption, and ensuring public safety. In urban areas where space is often limited, the presence of pre-existing utilities such as water pipes, sewage systems, electrical conduits, and communication lines can greatly complicate the installation of new district heating pipes.


Unexpected encounters with underground utilities can lead to substantial increases in project costs. These costs arise from emergency repairs, project delays, legal liabilities, and potential fines. When a utility is damaged it interrupts key services and can create risks to the public.  In response, repair teams must be called in immediately to fix the problem, often at a premium cost. Additionally, project timelines can be significantly extended as work stops to address the issue, leading to missed timetable targets and increased labor and equipment costs. By accurately identifying utility locations beforehand, these unforeseen expenses can be minimized. Efficiently managing the limited underground space available also helps to avoid costly rerouting and redesign efforts.

 


If the underground space is already densely occupied, finding suitable pathways for the district heating network becomes challenging. This can lead to the need for more complex and costly engineering solutions, such as rerouting existing utilities, employing advanced tunnelling methods, or even reconstructing certain sections of the underground network. Each of these measures can substantially increase the project's expenses and extend the timeline for completion. Moreover, the risk of damaging existing utilities during construction is higher in crowded underground environments, potentially leading to service disruptions, risk to the public, and additional repair costs. Therefore, comprehensive GIS input data of the existing infrastructure and meticulous planning are essential to identify the best possible routes and methods for integrating the district heating system with minimal impact.


The task of locating existing underground utilities has been significantly enhanced by modern technology. Ground-penetrating radar (GPR), electromagnetic induction, and infrastructure network digital twins coupled with GIS (Geographic Information Systems) are among the advanced tools available to survey and map underground infrastructures accurately. These technologies provide detailed and precise information, reducing the likelihood of errors and increasing the efficiency of the construction process. Investing in these technologies is crucial for ensuring that utility mapping is comprehensive and reliable, particularly when dealing with the spatial complexities of urban environments. This information is key input data for the district energy network design process.
 

 

The underground is a crowded space, with numerous utilities competing for room. The addition of district heating pipes must be carefully coordinated to fit within the existing infrastructure without causing conflicts. Each utility has specific requirements regarding proximity to other utilities due to safety, maintenance, and operational considerations. For instance, gas lines must be separated from electrical cables to prevent ignition risks, and water mains need to be accessible for repairs. Accurate mapping and strategic planning are essential to navigate these spatial constraints and ensure that the new district heating network can be integrated without compromising the functionality or safety of existing utilities.


In this context, Comsof Heat can play a vital role. Comsof Heat is a proven and validated automated design tool specifically tailored for district heating networks. Comsof Heat offers sophisticated capabilities that take into account the complexities of urban underground infrastructure as part of the network design process. The Comsof Heat software can interpret files containing data on existing underground utilities, enabling it to verify space constraints and adjust the estimated deployment cost of the heating network accordingly.
 

 

Comsof Heat district heating pipe network and the existing underground utilities.

By incorporating Comsof Heat into the planning process, engineers can ensure more accurate and efficient designs. The software's ability to analyse and integrate complex data sets means that potential conflicts with existing utilities can be identified and resolved early in the design phase rather than finding dangerous and costly surprises during construction. 


The integration of Comsof Heat’s automated planning capabilities into district heating network projects drives efficiency and cost-effectiveness in complex urban infrastructure development. As cities continue to grow and the demand for sustainable heating and cooling solutions increases, Comsof Heat helps engineers make informed design and construction decisions that are  indispensable in the planning and execution of these critical projects.

 


Comsof Heat district heating space availability in the underground based on the existing utilities.

 

In summary, considering existing utilities during the planning and design stages of a district heating network is essential. Limited underground space can significantly elevate costs and complicate the construction process, making early and thorough planning essential for a successful and cost-effective project. Comsof Heat provides a sophisticated and reliable automated planning solution to these challenges, ensuring that district heating networks are designed with precision and foresight, ultimately leading to more sustainable and efficient urban infrastructure. 


Learn more about the role of Comsof Heat automated planning in district energy projects.